PMS comparison · 2026
VS
Guesty
Hostfully vs Guesty: the better fit for growing property managers
Hostfully is The Growth PMS with 24/7 support for every customer, transparent pricing, and a platform that scales with you from 1 to 100+ properties. Guesty was built for enterprise and is priced accordingly. See the full comparison below, and why so many switched to Hostfully.
By submitting, you agree to receive email, phone, and SMS communications from Hostfully about your demo and follow-ups. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg Frequency may vary. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for help. Privacy Policy.
Trusted by leading vacation rental companies
Why operators leave Guesty for Hostfully
Real numbers from operators who made the switch, drawn from Hostfully's internal logs tracking each account's listing count before and after onboarding.
Grow your portfolio
256%
average growth in listing count after switching from Guesty
Source: Hostfully internal listing-count logs, before vs after onboarding.Cut software cost
~60%
lower total cost reported versus their prior Guesty setup
Source: Hostfully customer data.Rated by operators
4.8
Trustpilot rating, compared with 4.5 for Guesty
Source: Trustpilot, as of June 2026."Good pricing, dependable, and very good tech support at all times. Better pricing and service value than Guesty by far."
Figures reflect operators who moved from Guesty to Hostfully and are based on Hostfully internal data; individual results vary.
In short
Hostfully and Guesty are both vacation rental property management platforms, but they serve different operators. Guesty is built for large-scale and enterprise portfolios with the budget and team to run an expensive, feature-heavy platform. Hostfully is The Growth PMS for vacation rental operators moving from a small portfolio to a scalable business: enterprise-grade capability with hands-on support, transparent pricing, and the flexibility to use Hostfully all-in-one or connect the best tools for the job, without enterprise cost or complexity.
Choose Guesty if
You run 100+ properties, need white-label or multi-brand, and have the budget and in-house team to manage an enterprise platform with features most smaller operators never use.
Choose Hostfully if
You're a growing property manager with 1 to 100 properties who wants 24/7 support included, transparent upfront pricing, and the freedom to run all-in-one or integrate your own stack as you grow.
Free demo · guided migration · no onboarding fees
If you are weighing Hostfully against Guesty, you are probably past managing a couple of listings by hand and deciding which platform to build a real business on. Both are capable property management systems, and on paper their feature lists overlap. The difference that matters is who each one is built for. This comparison breaks down pricing, support, reliability, and growth fit side by side, with sourced customer feedback from both platforms, so you can see where each one fits before you commit.
The short version
Hostfully is The Growth PMS for vacation rental operators moving from a small portfolio to a scalable business. Guesty is an enterprise PMS built for large operators. The right choice depends on your budget, and whether you want to grow your business or be locked into enterprise workflows that are hard to use.
At a glance: Hostfully vs Guesty
How the two platforms compare on the points operators ask about most. Figures reflect publicly available information and user reviews as of June 2026; verify current pricing and features directly before deciding.
| Hostfully 4.8 Trustpilot | Guesty 4.5 Trustpilot | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | From $15/month per property | Varies; commonly starts around $35 to $40 per property (per public info) |
| Best for | Operators growing from 1 to 100 properties | Large-scale and enterprise portfolios (100+) |
| Not ideal for | Enterprises needing deep white-label / multi-brand | Operators from 1 to 100 paying enterprise prices for features they will not use |
| Primary strength | Support, transparency, owner tools, right-sized depth | Breadth of features and enterprise scale |
| Growth fit | Built to scale with you from small to professional | Strong at the top end; heavy for early-stage growth |
| Support model | 24/7 support included for every customer | Reported by users as tiered by subscription level |
| Migration difficulty | Guided onboarding with a dedicated rep included | Onboarding fees reported by users (up to ~$1,000) |
| Total cost risk | Transparent upfront pricing, no hidden fees | Users report add-on costs surfacing after signing |
| All-in-one or integrate | Run all-in-one or connect best-in-class tools; your choice | Tends toward add-ons within its own ecosystem, but offers integrations. |
| Reporting & analytics | Fully configurable, included | Reported by users as gated to higher tiers |
| Smart device support | 200+ devices native, ~$6/device | Locks native; ~$8, third-party for more (per public info) |
| Channel reliability | Rated highly by users for sync dependability | Vrbo sync issues reported in public reviews |
| Damage protection | Up to $50,000 with Screen & Protect | Reported cap around $20,000 at $20 per night (verify current terms) |
| Trustpilot rating | 4.8 (as of June 2026) | 4.5 (as of June 2026) |
Comparison based on publicly available pricing, product information, and user reviews on Trustpilot, Capterra, and Software Advice as of June 2026. Competitor pricing and features change; figures here are reported values, not guarantees. Verify directly with each provider before making a decision.
Reliability you can count on. Hostfully holds preferred and premium partner status with:
The features that help growing property managers stay ahead, and how the two compare
Click through each area to see where Hostfully pulls ahead of Guesty.
Channel manager
Hostfully is rated highly by property managers for keeping channels in sync and operations running smoothly. Guesty offers similar channel coverage, but sync issues with Vrbo and other platforms have been reported across public review sites.
See it in a demo
Owner portal
Hostfully's owner portal is a polished, client-facing tool built to help property managers maintain and grow owner relationships, which matters as you take on more owners. Guesty offers an owner portal too, though some users have reported inconsistencies in its financial analytics and reporting accuracy.
See it in a demo
Smart locks and devices
Hostfully supports 200+ smart devices natively, including locks, thermostats, and noise monitors, at roughly $6 per device. Based on public information, Guesty's native support covers locks, with other devices requiring third-party tools at around $8.
See it in a demo
Transparent pricing, pay for what you use
Hostfully keeps pricing upfront, with no surprise charges. Across public reviews, Guesty customers have reported unexpected costs after signing on, with add-ons treated as separate upsells. This is the kind of cost risk that grows with your portfolio.
Hostfully starts at $15 per month per property. Guesty commonly starts in the $35 to $40 per property range based on public information, and much of its feature set and cost is aimed at portfolios far bigger than a 1 to 100 operator's. Many smaller operators end up paying enterprise prices for capabilities they will never use.
See it in a demo
Reporting and analytics
Hostfully gives every customer fully configurable reporting out of the box, with no upgrade required. Users report that with Guesty, fuller reporting and analytics sit behind higher tiers.
See it in a demo
Damage protection
Hostfully protects properties up to $50,000 when Screen & Protect is activated, at $8.50 per night, or $5 per night for stays of 31 nights or more. Based on publicly reported terms, Guesty's coverage caps around $20,000 at $20 per night. Verify current terms with each provider, as damage protection rates and coverage change regularly.
See it in a demo
Onboarding and support
Hostfully assigns a dedicated onboarding rep who stays with you through setup, and every customer gets 24/7 support on any tier. Guesty customers have reported in public reviews waiting days for replies and paying onboarding fees up to around $1,000. Support quality and time-to-resolution matter most in the early growth stages, when you are still building your systems.
See it in a demo
One platform, not two
It is worth knowing that Guesty effectively runs two separate products: a free or low-cost entry-level tool aimed at individual hosts, and a separate, more expensive platform for professional operators. Users often report that the entry-level product feels limited, and that growing past it means moving onto the pricier professional product rather than simply scaling up. Hostfully is one platform. You start where you are and grow on the same system, without switching products or relearning your setup as your portfolio expands.
See it in a demo
Automations
Both platforms automate the operational basics. Hostfully's setup is built to be fast and intuitive. In public reviews, some Guesty users have flagged the automation setup process as a friction point worth weighing before you commit.
See it in a demo
Which one is the best choice for you?
A quick way to read the comparison by scenario. For most operators in the 1 to 100 range, Hostfully is the stronger fit; Guesty pulls ahead at true enterprise scale.
| Scenario | Best choice |
|---|---|
| 1 to 20 properties | Hostfully |
| 20 to 50 properties | Hostfully |
| 50 to 100 properties | Hostfully |
| 100+ properties | Guesty |
| Direct bookings | Hostfully |
| Low cost | Hostfully |
| Enterprise workflows | Guesty |
The story behind the numbers
Averages tell you the pattern. A single operator tells you whether it is real. Here is one who lived the switch.
Four platforms tried, then Hostfully: Anchor Realty Group
Kaitlyn Hough-Oakes of Anchor Realty Group assessed four platforms before choosing Hostfully, ruling out Guesty as too expensive to justify and others as too technical. Today she runs 70+ booking channels from one platform.
"We can book someone in like 5 seconds. I can handle everything with Hostfully, and it takes care of the rest."
Kaitlyn Hough-Oakes, Anchor Realty Group · Virginia Beach · 20+ properties · with Hostfully since 2023
What property managers say about Hostfully
Independent reviews on Trustpilot, Capterra, and G2 point consistently to the same strengths: responsive support, dependable channel sync, and owner tools that hold up as a portfolio grows. Hostfully holds a 4.8 rating on Trustpilot as of June 2026, compared with 4.5 for Guesty.
"Intuitive, customizable, and outstanding support — best PMS experience yet. I have tried 3 previous PMS softwares but this has been the best experience by far."
David L., G2 · [source]
"The Hostfully software saves me a lot of time managing a 7-room Airbnb rooming house plus another 5-bedroom house. I now have time to work a full-time job and manage my properties."
Reginald Howard, Trustpilot · [source]
"This is a great platform to centralize the management of all your listings across different channels and increase your revenue."
Rodrigo O., Capterra · [source]
"The platform is intuitive and does not require a computer science degree to learn and use."
Roac LLC, Trustpilot · [source]
What independent sources say about Guesty
We are biased, so here is what we are not asking you to take on faith. The themes below come from public reviews and community threads, grouped to match the comparison points above. Each is framed as reported by users, with a named source, so you can read it in full.
Channel reliability
Channel-sync complaints recur across public review platforms. A widely read r/airbnb_hosts thread advising hosts against Guesty reported Vrbo listings going offline or showing inaccurate information for roughly six weeks, which users cite as one of the more common integration failures. (Source: r/airbnb_hosts; as of June 2026.)
"This did not work for me and resulted in my VRBO listings being either offline or inaccurate for 6 weeks."
Verified user, r/airbnb_hosts · Read on Reddit
"The VRBO integration was particularly problematic, resulting in syncing errors and ongoing manual oversight."
Verified reviewer, Capterra · Read on Capterra
Pricing transparency
Based on public reviews on Trustpilot and in operator communities, some users cite billing issues, charges that did not match what was agreed, and ongoing back-and-forth to get them corrected. (Source: Trustpilot, operator Facebook groups; as of June 2026.)
"It's been a constant battle with billing issues and charges that don't align with what was agreed to."
Verified reviewer, Trustpilot · Read on Trustpilot
"They will keep charging you without explaining what for."
Verified host, Facebook Group · Read on Facebook
Onboarding and support
Support is a recurring theme in public reviews. One Capterra reviewer described a "love hate relationship," reporting a premium price alongside support that was hard to reach. Users note that because support access is tiered, smaller customers can get less help. (Source: Capterra; as of June 2026.)
"Support is the biggest let down... the pages of manuals they have online are not user friendly."
Verified reviewer, Capterra · Read on Capterra
"It takes an hour with a chat bot to get a referral to a live rep."
Verified reviewer, Trustpilot · Read on Trustpilot
Industry sentiment
Synthesized from independent reviews and community discussion across major platforms, as of June 2026:
On Guesty: A well-known PMS with a broad feature set, built primarily for large-scale operators. Users frequently report reliability issues with non-Airbnb channel integrations, a pricing model with add-ons and upsells, and a support structure that can deprioritize smaller customers. That combination can frustrate operators who lack the budget or bandwidth to manage its complexity.
On Hostfully: Built around reliability, transparency, and ease of use. Every customer, regardless of portfolio size, gets responsive 24/7 support, configurable reporting, and a platform refined on real user feedback. The result is a PMS that gives property managers room to grow without surprise charges or integration headaches.
Public rating & review themes
4.8
Trustpilot ratings as of June 2026. Themes from public reviews cited above.
Worried about switching?
Worried about missed cleanings or double bookings during a PMS switch? Hostfully makes the transition simple. Follow a personalized onboarding plan, run your existing PMS alongside Hostfully during setup, and lean on 24/7 support, live office hours, Hostfully University, and a dedicated Software Advisor every step of the way.
See how migration works
"Switching to Hostfully allowed me to list all the properties on Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com. Hostfully has allowed us to grow beyond what we could have hoped for."
Nick Halverson, OSA Property Management · switched to Hostfully
Choosing Hostfully as your Growth PMS
A few questions that come up once operators have decided Guesty is not the right fit, and are thinking about where their business is headed next.
Which is better for growing operators?
Hostfully is The Growth PMS, built to take operators from a small portfolio to a scalable business with owner tools, automation, and integrations that grow with them. Guesty is strong at enterprise scale but can feel heavy in the early and middle stages of growth.
Will I outgrow Hostfully like I might a starter tool?
No. Hostfully is built to carry you across stages, from your first few units to a professionalized business with teams and owners. The features you need next are already there when you reach for them, so growth never means starting over on a new platform.
Why does growth fit matter when choosing a PMS?
The cost of switching platforms is highest once you have properties, owners, and systems in place. Choosing a PMS built to scale with you means you are not forced to re-platform the moment you outgrow a starter tool or feel boxed in by an enterprise one.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hostfully better than Guesty?
It depends on your portfolio size. Guesty is built for large-scale and enterprise operators. For operators running 1 to 100 properties, Hostfully is generally the better fit, with 24/7 support included for every customer, transparent pricing, and the freedom to run all-in-one or integrate the tools you choose. Hostfully is The Growth PMS for operators moving from a small portfolio to a scalable business.
What is the best Guesty alternative?
For operators running 1 to 100 properties, Hostfully is a leading Guesty alternative. It offers 24/7 support for every customer, transparent upfront pricing, and the flexibility to run all-in-one or connect best-in-class tools, without enterprise complexity, and it is built to scale as the business grows.
How does Hostfully vs Guesty pricing compare?
Hostfully uses transparent upfront pricing with no hidden fees, and includes support, reporting, and onboarding. Based on public reviews, Guesty customers report add-on costs surfacing after signing. For operators in the 1 to 100 property range, Hostfully typically carries lower total cost risk.
How does Hostfully vs Guesty support compare?
Hostfully includes 24/7 support for every customer on any tier, plus a dedicated onboarding rep. Users report that Guesty's support access is tiered by subscription level, so smaller customers can get less help. Support quality is a recurring theme in public Guesty reviews.
Is Hostfully or Guesty better for small property managers?
Guesty is built primarily for large-scale and enterprise operators, and smaller managers often find its pricing and tier-based support a poor fit. Hostfully is designed for operators running 1 to 100 properties, with included support and transparent pricing, which makes it a stronger fit for small property managers.
How hard is it to switch from Guesty to Hostfully?
Hostfully assigns a dedicated onboarding rep and builds the migration around your timeline, with 400+ help articles, Hostfully University, and 24/7 support along the way. Most operators move without losing momentum on bookings.
Who switches from Guesty to Hostfully?
Operators who switch from Guesty to Hostfully typically run 5 to 100 properties and are dealing with rising software costs, frustration with tiered support, and a desire for simpler operations and better owner reporting. They have outgrown a starter setup but are not enterprise, and they want capability without enterprise cost or complexity.
Operators who tend to stay on Guesty usually run 100+ properties across multiple brands, with dedicated operations teams and enterprise reporting requirements. In short, Guesty fits enterprise-scale portfolios, while growing operators in the 5 to 100 range are the ones who most often move to Hostfully.
Enterprise power without the enterprise price tag.
Get 24/7 support, transparent pricing, and the freedom to run all-in-one or build your own stack, for operators growing from 1 to 100 properties. Make the switch today.
By submitting, you agree to receive email, phone, and SMS communications from Hostfully about your demo and follow-ups. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg Frequency may vary. Reply STOP to opt out or HELP for help. Privacy Policy.
Sources used in this comparison: Trustpilot, G2, Capterra, Software Advice, Reddit, and Hostfully customer data. Comparison reflects publicly available information and user reviews as of June 2026; competitor pricing and features change, so verify directly with each provider before deciding.
